• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
The Daily Dish
  • About Me
  • Recipes
  • Wellbeing🧡
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Gluten-Free
  • Navigation Menu: Social Icons

    Connect With Me

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
menu icon
go to homepage
  • About Me
  • Recipes
  • Wellbeing🧡
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Gluten-Free
  • Let's Connect

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • About Me
    • Recipes
    • Wellbeing🧡
    • Contact
    • Subscribe
    • Gluten-Free
  • Let's Connect

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    • 10 Clever Ways To Use Up Leftover Cranberry Sauce
    • 13 Of Georgia’s Best Puerto Rican Restaurants, Ranked
    • 15 One-Of-A-Kind North Carolina Eateries Worth Adding To Your Bucket List
    • 14 Virginia Restaurants That Belong On Every Foodie’s Bucket List
    • 12 Best Long Island, New York Steakhouses That Never Disappoint
    • 12 Minnesota Restaurants Where Dinner Feels Like An Event, Not Just A Meal
    • 14 New York Italian Spots Where The Portions Are Big Enough To Take Home
    • 11 Brussels Sprout Recipes That Might Change Your Mind About Them
    • 14 Michigan Polish Restaurants Keeping Old-World Recipes Alive
    • 12 Kentucky Restaurants That Taste Like Grandma’s Kitchen
    • 13 North Carolina Soul Food Spots Where Sunday Dinner Never Ends
    • 10 Chicago, Illinois Pizza Spots That Made Deep-Dish Famous
    Home » Food news & trends

    14 Florida Italian Restaurants You Can’t Leave The State Without Trying

    Published:Nov 18, 2026· Modified: Nov 18, 2026 by Ella Green

    • Share
    • Email

    A giant wheel of cheese gets turned into a mixing bowl for your pasta, right beside your table. Yes, that happens in Florida, a few blocks from the sand.

    Elsewhere, cooks fold pear into little pasta purses. One kitchen follows the seafood traditions of Rimini, a beach city on Italy's Adriatic coast. Tuxedo-clad waiters still glide through another dining room while live music plays.

    A couple of spots even stay open until midnight, which is handy after a late flight.

    You came for the sunshine, sure. But somewhere between the theme parks and the shell shops, you'll get hungry. A sad plate of chain-restaurant spaghetti is not the answer.

    You deserve a red sauce that tastes like somebody's grandmother is guarding the pot. Napkins tucked in, please.

    The best part? These kitchens stretch from the Panhandle down the Gulf Coast and over to South Beach. So which one gets your first forkful, the cheese wheel or the pear pasta?

    1. That's Amore

    That's Amore
    © That's Amore

    Ocean Drive has plenty of neon, but this spot adds a little romance to the strip. Desserts finished right at your table make the ending feel like a small show.

    Pasta is the main event. The Rigatoni Carbonara and the Ravioli All'Aragosta, stuffed with lobster, are two signature plates.

    Want something a bit fancy? Try the Gnocchi Cacio E Pepe And Truffle, soft potato dumplings with cheese, pepper, and truffle.

    Starters cover the sea and the garden. Grilled Octopus sits next to Burrata E Pomodori, creamy cheese with tomatoes.

    Plant-based eaters get a full vegan menu, which is rare in this neighborhood. The Penne in a creamy tomato sauce and the Bruschetta both appear on it.

    Here's a fun bonus: rooftop seating. Dogs are allowed inside and outside, so your four-legged travel buddy doesn't have to wait at the hotel.

    Doors open at noon and close at midnight daily. Friday and Saturday nights fill up, so a reservation saves you from pacing the sidewalk.

    Address: 620 Ocean Dr, Miami Beach, FL 33139

    2. Donatello Italian Restaurant

    Donatello Italian Restaurant
    © Donatello Italian Restaurant

    Tuxedos, stucco arches, and live music? Somebody clearly told Tampa that date night should feel like a classic movie.

    Donatello leans fully into old-school, upscale Italian dining. Waiters in tuxedos move through the room, and the setting feels made for anniversaries.

    The menu sticks to timeless favorites. Ossobucco, a slow-cooked veal shank, is one of the headliners.

    Hungry for pasta? Crab-filled pasta shows up among the entrees, alongside tenderloin and lamb for the meat lovers.

    Calamari Fritti makes an easy starter to share. Carpaccio Di Filetto, thin slices of beef, is the choice if you like something lighter.

    Save room, because dessert matters here. The Chocolate Mousse Cake and the cannoli pair nicely with an espresso.

    Dinner starts at 5 PM daily and runs later on Fridays and Saturdays. Saturday evenings draw the biggest crowd, so reservations are smart.

    Parking is easy, with an on-site lot and valet service. A private dining room handles bigger celebrations.

    Address: 232 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33609

    3. Osteria Natalina

    Osteria Natalina
    © Osteria Natalina

    Rimini is a beach town on Italy's Adriatic coast. Lucky for you, its cooking style lives on MacDill Avenue in South Tampa.

    Osteria Natalina keeps things informal and small. The kitchen focuses on Rimini-style dishes, with a real soft spot for seafood.

    Pear-stuffed sacchettini is a standout. These little pasta purses taste sweet and savory at once.

    Seafood lovers can go for the lobster and crab pasta. A bone-in veal steak covers the heartier side of the menu.

    Check the Lasagna Del Giorno, which changes by the day. The gnocchi and the Caprese Salad round out a classic lineup.

    End with tiramisu and a coffee. It is the polite thing to do.

    Plan carefully, because the osteria doesn't take reservations. Dinner runs Tuesday through Sunday from 5:30 PM, and Mondays are closed.

    Wednesday and Thursday nights tend to be quieter. Free parking nearby makes the trip easy.

    Address: 3215 S MacDill Ave, Tampa, FL 33629

    4. F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen

    F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen
    © F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen

    Can't decide between pizza and pasta? Good news, this Orlando scratch kitchen does both with a wood fire behind them.

    F&D sits on Curry Ford Road, far from the theme park traffic. The dining room has a sleek look, and the pasta is made fresh.

    The Margherita Pizza with Basil is a solid test of any wood oven. It keeps things simple and lets the crust do the talking.

    Pasta fans should eye the Pesto Cream Tortellini. Shrimp Scampi and Chicken Marsala cover the classic side of the menu.

    Meatballs Al Forno, baked in the oven, make a great opener. So does the F&D Garlic Bread, which disappears fast at most tables.

    Families get a kids' menu and high chairs. Dogs are welcome at the outdoor seats.

    Weekend lunches start at 11 AM on Saturday and Sunday. Weeknights open at 4 PM, so an early dinner is easy to grab.

    Address: 2635 Curry Ford Rd, Orlando, FL 32806

    5. Papparella Trattoria

    Papparella Trattoria
    © Papparella Trattoria

    Banoffee in a calzone sounds like a dare. At Papparella, it is a real dessert, and it might steal the show.

    This trattoria sits along the Sand Lake Road restaurant row in Orlando. The menu mixes signature pizzas with refined pasta and meat dishes.

    Start with Pappa's Burrata, soft and creamy. Then try the Margherita Verace, a pizza built around classic Neapolitan flavors.

    The Rigatoni Tartufato brings truffle to the table. Rigatoni Alla Vodka & Stracciatella adds a scoop of rich, shreddy cheese on top.

    Fettuccine Alla Nonno Carlo is named for a grandfather. That tells you a lot about the spirit of the kitchen.

    The room can feel quiet and romantic, yet kids are welcome. High chairs, a changing table, and a kids' menu are all available.

    Expect a wait on Friday and Saturday nights. Reservations are recommended for both lunch and dinner, and the free parking lot helps.

    Address: 6002 Sand Lake Vista Dr #100, Orlando, FL 32819

    6. Catullo’s Italian

    Catullo’s Italian
    © Catullo’s Italian

    Pear fiocchi might be the most famous little pasta bundle in Jacksonville. It is the signature dish here, and people line up for it.

    Catullo's cooks from scratch with a family-style feel. Homemade pasta anchors the menu, and the bread arrives as part of the meal.

    Craving something crispy? Arancini, fried rice balls, and Fried Mozzarella make strong first bites.

    Sea Scallop Risotto is a creamy choice for seafood lovers. The sausage and peppers feature locally made sausage, which gives the dish extra character.

    Burrata Salad keeps things fresh. Cannoli wraps up the night with a sweet crunch.

    Timing matters at this spot. Catullo's doesn't take reservations, and there is usually a wait.

    Dinner runs Monday through Saturday, and Sundays are closed. Saturday opens at 4 PM, so an early arrival is your best trick.

    Parking is free and usually easy to find. That is one less thing to worry about.

    Address: 1650-2 San Pablo Rd S, Jacksonville, FL 32224

    7. Bella Vista A Mare

    Bella Vista A Mare
    © Bella Vista A Mare

    Your pasta takes a spin inside a giant wheel of cheese before it lands on your plate. That tableside move is the headline act at Bella Vista A Mare.

    The restaurant sits a short walk from the sand in Jacksonville Beach. Its menu balances that signature showpiece with traditional Italian classics.

    Hungry for comfort? The Ultimate creamy tomato chicken parm combines two favorites into one hearty plate.

    Chicken Francese offers a lighter, lemony option. Pappardelle Bolognese brings wide noodles with a rich meat sauce.

    Kids get their own menu, which makes family dinners easier. Groups fit in well, too.

    Hours start at 4 PM Tuesday through Friday. Weekends open earlier, at 2 PM on Saturday and Sunday.

    Mondays are closed, so plan around that. Friday and Saturday evenings bring the biggest crowds.

    Reservations are accepted and worth making. Free parking and valet service keep arrival simple after a beach day.

    Address: 311 3rd St N #101, Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250

    8. Casa Benedetto's

    Casa Benedetto's
    © Casa Benedetto's

    Eggplant caponata with your bread basket is a strong opening move. Casa Benedetto's serves it, and the night only gets better from there.

    This casual St. Augustine spot has a retro look and homey touches. The menu sticks to Southern Italian, home-style cooking.

    The chicken parmesan gets crispy on the outside and stays tender inside. Homemade red sauce covers penne and eggplant parm, too.

    Lunch fans can go for the 12-inch meatball sub. Escarole and beans make a hearty, old-fashioned side.

    Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Francese, and Shrimp Scampi round out the classics. Stuffed Mushrooms make a handy shared starter.

    Finish with cannoli or tiramisu. Your sweet tooth will thank you.

    The restaurant opens at noon Monday through Saturday and closes on Sundays. Outdoor tables are available on nice days.

    Families will find a kids' menu and high chairs. Dogs are allowed inside, which is a rare treat.

    Address: 197 Blackford Way, St. Augustine, FL 32086

    9. Viola's

    Viola's
    © Viola's

    Out on A1A, south of downtown St. Augustine, a family-run bistro keeps its brick oven busy. Violas is the kind of place you mention to friends right after you leave.

    The menu covers classic Italian favorites. Brick-oven pizza and custom pastas are the backbone.

    Pizza lovers should try the Garlic White pizza. Its crust comes out crisp yet soft and airy.

    Lasagna, Chicken Marsala, and Shrimp Scampi deliver the comfort. The meatballs and clam sauce also earn a spot on your order.

    Want something handheld? Calzone and Stromboli are both on the menu.

    Calamari works as a shared starter. Tiramisu makes a sweet, creamy finish.

    Violas opens Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 8 PM. Mondays and Tuesdays are closed.

    Families get high chairs and a kids' menu. Dogs can hang out at the outdoor seating.

    Address: 6149 A1A S, St. Augustine, FL 32080

    10. Caffé Milano Naples

    Caffé Milano Naples
    © Caffé Milano Naples

    Handmade gnocchi on Fifth Avenue South is a solid reason to slow down your shopping trip. Caffé Milano serves it in a modern, polished space.

    The menu runs from pizza and pasta to sandwiches. That variety makes it an easy pick for lunch or dinner.

    Gnocchi Sorrentina comes baked with tomato and cheese. Ravioli of the Day keeps regular visits interesting.

    Seafood risotto is a strong choice for ocean lovers. Tuna Tartare offers a lighter, fresh start.

    Craving pure comfort? The Lasagna and Veal Parmigiana both hit that spot.

    Do not skip the tiramisu. It is one of the house signatures.

    Hours start at 11:30 AM daily and stretch late into the evening. Saturday nights are the busiest, so reserve ahead.

    Outdoor seating lets you watch Fifth Avenue stroll by. Dogs are welcome inside and out, and kids get their own menu.

    Address: 800 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102

    11. La Trattoria

    La Trattoria
    © La Trattoria

    Red-checked tablecloths never go out of style. La Trattoria proves it a few doors down Fifth Avenue South in Naples.

    This buzzy trattoria serves Neapolitan pizza, pasta, and plenty of Italian favorites. A sidewalk patio adds romance to an evening out.

    The Bucatini Cacio E Pepe gets a fancy upgrade. Shaved black truffles go right on top.

    Pizza fans can pick the Pizza Quattro Formaggi. It packs four cheeses onto one pie.

    Seafood shows up in a big way, too. Fritto Misto and Salmon Piccata both deserve a look.

    Sharing with friends? Start with the Antipasto Italiano and the Trattoria Salad.

    Chicken Parmigiana covers the classic comfort corner. Kids get their own menu as well.

    Doors open at 4 PM daily. Fridays and Saturdays run until midnight, so a late bite is possible.

    Address: 878 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102

    12. Sara's Italian Kitchen

    Sara's Italian Kitchen
    © Sara's Italian Kitchen

    A family-run kitchen with homemade pasta and a signature tiramisu is basically a Sarasota secret handshake. Sara's Italian Kitchen keeps it simple and charming.

    The restaurant sits on Gateway Avenue, away from the busy downtown streets. Its focus stays on authentic, homemade pasta.

    Carbonara is a highlight. Creamy, peppery, and comforting, it fits any lunch or dinner.

    Prefer something heartier? Veal Parmigiana brings the classic crunch and sauce.

    Lighter eaters can pick the Mediterranean Salad. It makes a fresh partner for a pasta plate.

    Then comes the tiramisu, the dish the kitchen is known for. Order it even if you claim you're full.

    The mood stays casual and quiet. That makes it a nice break after a busy beach day.

    Hours run Tuesday through Sunday, 11 AM to 9 PM, and Mondays are closed. Dogs are welcome inside and out, and parking is free.

    Address: 6538 Gateway Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231

    13. Nōnnō Umberto

    Nōnnō Umberto
    © Nōnnō Umberto

    Three restaurants in one name? Nōnnō Umberto calls itself Italian, seafood, and steakhouse, and the menu backs that up.

    You'll find it on St. Armands Circle in Sarasota, right off the Boulevard of the Presidents. That makes it a handy stop between shops and the beach.

    Homemade pasta leads the way. Fettuccine and Tagliatelle are two favorites to try.

    Seafood comes wild-caught, which matters on the Gulf Coast. The Octopus is a smart order for adventurous eaters.

    Carpaccio makes a light, elegant opener. Brick-oven pizzas give groups something easy to share.

    Live music adds a fun soundtrack on some nights. Outdoor seating lets you enjoy the island breeze.

    Families get high chairs, a changing table, and a kids' menu. Dogs can join you outdoors.

    The kitchen serves from 11 AM to 9:30 PM every day. Saturday evenings are busiest, so reserve a table.

    Address: 22 S Boulevard of the Presidents, Sarasota, FL 34236

    14. Tour of Italy

    Tour of Italy
    © Tour of Italy

    Garlic rolls deserve their own fan club, and Tallahassee has a strong candidate. Tour of Italy serves them alongside hearty lasagna and pizza.

    This small, intimate spot sits on North Monroe Street. It keeps the focus on traditional Italian cooking without any fuss.

    Eggplant lasagna is a nice twist on the classic. Veal Marsala brings a rich sauce for meat lovers.

    Pizza nights call for the Supreme Pizza. Spaghetti with Meat Sauce covers the old-school craving.

    Vegetarians can lean on the Eggplant Parmigiana. The Greek Salad and Bruschetta add fresh options.

    Dessert has a fun surprise. The cannoli come covered in chocolate, and tiramisu is on the menu too.

    Lunch runs Tuesday through Friday, with a short break before dinner. Saturday opens at noon, while Sundays and Mondays are closed.

    Indoor and outdoor seats are both available. Kids get their own menu, and parking is free.

    Address: 3813 N Monroe St Ste 21, Tallahassee, FL 32303

    More Food news & trends

    • 12 Old-School Maryland Crab Houses Locals Love
    • 11 Wisconsin Friday Fish Fries Worth Showing Up Early For
    • 12 Savannah, Georgia Restaurants Where Lowcountry Cooking Shines
    • 13 Ohio Diners Where Locals Have Had The Same Booth For Years

    Primary Sidebar

    Keri Bevan

    Welcome, I'm Keri

    I'm the food photographer and recipe developer and writer behind Daily Dish.

    More About Me
    SUBSCRIBE

    Popular Posts

    • 14 Florida Italian Restaurants You Can’t Leave The State Without Trying
    • 12 Christmas Canapés That Look Fancy But Take Minutes To Make
    • 13 Missouri Mexican Joints Locals Swear Are The Best In The State
    • 13 Kentucky Spots Serving Fried Chicken Better Than Any Chain

    Cozy Soups

    • Fava bean soup in a ceramic bowl.
      Fava Bean Soup
    • Vegan potato soup in a bowl with chives and croutons.
      Creamy Vegan Potato Soup
    • Bok choy soup with garlic and ginger.
      Bok Choy Soup With Garlic & Ginger
    • gluten free and dairy free tomato soup
      Creamy Gluten Free And Dairy Free Tomato Soup
    Company logs of people I have worked with.

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    Recipes

    • Breakfast
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Sauces and Dips
    • Gluten Free

    Newsletter

    • Sign Up! for emails and updates

    Contact

    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Daily Dish Web Stories

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

    Copyright © 2024 Daily Dish