One Long Island steakhouse keeps its cellar inside an old bank vault. Another once hosted Theodore Roosevelt. You came for a porterhouse, and you leave with a story.
The beef out here gets serious attention. Some kitchens age their meat right on-site, and one spot pairs a tomahawk with sushi rolls. A few rooms have fireplaces, and a couple add live music to the mix.
You know the moment the steak hits the table and the conversation stops? That's the goal at these places. Creamed spinach, baked clams, and banana cream pie keep showing up too, and nobody seems to mind.
New York gets plenty of credit for its city steakhouses. Long Island quietly holds its own, from old houses near the water to a lodge full of steer decor. So which one gets your next birthday dinner, and which one gets your next random Tuesday?
1. George Martin's Strip Steak

A steakhouse inside a turn-of-the-20th-century house sounds like a plot from an old movie. In Great River, it's just Wednesday dinner.
George Martin's Strip Steak serves its chops with a 1920s twist. The quaint old house sets the mood before you even open the menu.
Steaks here come out precisely cooked and nicely seasoned. The kitchen treats each cut with real care, and it shows on the plate.
Sharing is the smart move. The porterhouse for two is a popular pick, and the chopped salad makes a crisp partner for it.
Fresh seafood also earns its place on the menu. Servers know the dishes well, so ask them for guidance if you can't decide.
A fireplace adds charm on chilly nights. Live music fills the room at times, giving dinner a relaxed, romantic feel.
Plan ahead, because the doors stay closed on Monday and Tuesday. Saturday evening gets busy, so reservations are a wise idea.
Free parking makes arrival easy. Desserts and coffee round things out nicely, so leave a little room.
Address: 60 River Rd, Great River, NY 11739
2. Peter Luger Steak House

Brooklyn's most famous steak family has a Long Island branch. Lucky you, because the Great Neck location skips the bridge traffic.
Peter Luger keeps the focus on high-quality beef. The room feels classic and historic, with zero fuss and no pretense.
The rib steak is a top choice on the menu. Many diners also go straight for the famous porterhouse, sliced and ready to share.
Start with Luger Bacon, a thick slab that has its own fan club. The iceberg wedge salad adds a cool, crunchy break.
Sides matter here too. Creamed spinach and Luger's Special German Fried Potatoes are the classic pairing.
Craving something simpler at lunch? The Luger Burger is a solid midday option, and lunch runs daily.
Save room for the hot fudge sundae. It's a sweet, old-school finish that suits the room perfectly.
Bring cash or check payment options before you go. Reservations are recommended, and Saturday evenings fill up fast.
Valet and street parking are both available. That makes the trip a little smoother on busy nights.
Address: 255 Northern Blvd, Great Neck, NY 11021
3. Bryant & Cooper

Patience is the secret ingredient in Roslyn. Bryant & Cooper ages its meats right on-site, and the waiting pays off.
The room blends old-world charm with a lively buzz. A fireplace adds a touch of comfort when the weather turns cold.
Steaks lead the show, of course. Still, the seafood holds its own, with tuna tartare and lemon sole on the menu.
Traditional sides keep things classic. Creamed spinach and Brussels sprouts both make strong cases for a spot on your table.
Here's where it gets tricky. The dessert list includes pecan pie, banana cream pie, and crème brûlée.
How do you choose just one? You probably don't, and sharing is the friendly answer anyway.
Staff know the menu well and keep things moving. The service feels polished without slowing your meal down.
Lunch runs on weekdays, which is handy for a midday treat. Reservations are recommended, since a wait is common.
Parking is easy with a free lot and valet service. Free Wi-Fi is even available, though your steak deserves full attention.
Address: 2 Middle Neck Rd, Roslyn, NY 11576
4. Pace's Steak House

Old-school vibes never really go out of style. Pace's Steak House in Hauppauge proves it with live music and a lively dining room.
Dry-aged beef is the signature here. The New York Shell Steak is a menu highlight, and the filet earns plenty of praise too.
Love a good starter? French onion soup and lobster bisque both warm you up before the main event.
Baked clams are another solid opener. They bring a taste of the shore to a classic steakhouse table.
Don't skip Jackson's Mac & Cheese. It's the kind of side that disappears before anyone admits taking seconds.
Scallops show up for seafood fans. The kitchen handles both surf and turf with real skill.
The lounge area sits apart from the dining room. That gives you a choice between lively energy and a calmer meal.
A fireplace adds charm, and desserts lean rich. Coffee pairs nicely if you want to linger a bit longer.
Lunch runs on weekdays. Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially midweek and Saturday evenings.
Address: 325 Smithtown Bypass, Hauppauge, NY 11788
5. Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi

Can't decide between a tomahawk steak and sushi rolls? Insignia in Smithtown politely says you don't have to.
The colorful decor sets a fun, upscale tone. A glass display and a patio with a fireplace add some extra style.
Steak fans have plenty to explore. The Kansas City Sirloin, NY strip, and tomahawk all appear on the menu.
Sushi lovers get their moment too. The Family Sushi Platter makes sharing easy for groups.
Seafood starters keep the table busy. Think colossal crab cocktail, a jumbo lump crab cake, and crispy calamari.
Want something off the beaten path? Chilean sea bass with pineapple fried rice is a fun twist.
The Insignia Salad offers a lighter start. Cheesecake makes a sweet finish if you still have room.
Families feel welcome here, and high chairs are available. Brunch is also on the schedule for a slower weekend meal.
Reservations are recommended, especially on Saturday evening. Valet and a free lot make parking simple.
Address: 610 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown, NY 11787
6. Rothmann's Steakhouse

Theodore Roosevelt once dined at this East Norwich landmark. Now you can grab a seat and make your own history.
Rothmann's Steakhouse feels formal and refined. The setting is beautiful, which makes it a natural pick for special occasions.
Big appetites, take note. The Wagyu Porter for 2 and the 18-ounce rib steak lead the menu.
The tomahawk ribeye also gets plenty of love. Truffle fries and sweet potato mash make tasty sidekicks.
Craving seafood? The Seafood Plateau brings a grand spread to the table.
Creamed spinach is a must for many. Asparagus and applewood smoked bacon round out the side lineup.
Sunday is a big day here. Brunch starts in the morning, and it's the busiest time of the week.
Dessert keeps it classic with crème brûlée and New York cheesecake. Coffee makes a smooth final note.
A fireplace adds charm to cooler evenings. Reservations are recommended, and free parking takes the stress off arrival.
Address: 6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732
7. Blackstone Steakhouse

Business lunches get a serious upgrade in Melville. Blackstone Steakhouse pairs prime meats with a polished power-lunch feel.
Wood accents give the room a handsome look. The energy picks up as the day goes on, especially on Saturday evenings.
Prime steaks share the spotlight with sushi and seafood. Mussels and bay scallops make a fine starter for the table.
Wagyu Sliders are a fun way to begin. They give you a taste of rich beef before the main course arrives.
Macaroni and cheese with lobster is pure comfort. It's a side that happily steals attention from the steak.
The Blackstone Salad offers a lighter option. Chicken with creamy mashed potatoes also shows up for non-steak eaters.
Finish with the chocolate cake. It's a classic ending that rarely disappoints a sweet tooth.
Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are allowed outside. Brunch and lunch are both on the menu too.
Families are welcome, with high chairs ready. Valet parking and a free lot make arrival easy.
Address: 10 Pinelawn Rd, Melville, NY 11747
8. Tellers: An American Chophouse

Money used to change hands here. Today, the only deposits in this Islip building are steaks landing on your table.
Tellers sits inside a former bank with high ceilings. A copper counter and an old vault keep the history front and center.
The Cowgirl Ribeye is a menu star. The 21-day aged strip steak also earns big praise from steak fans.
Seafood starters make a strong opening. Oysters on the half shell and Tellers Baked Clams are both on offer.
Sides bring plenty of comfort. Lobster mac and cheese and burnt broccoli make a tasty pair.
Got room for dessert? Crème brûlée and banana cream pie wrap things up sweetly.
Terrace seating is available when the weather is nice. Inside, the lounge area feels relaxed and inviting.
Lunch starts at 11:30 AM daily. Brunch is also on the schedule for a slower morning.
Friday and Saturday evenings get busy. Reservations are recommended, and free parking keeps things easy.
Address: 605 E Main St, Islip, NY 11751
9. Vintage Steak House

Steer decor on the walls is a pretty clear hint about dinner. Vintage Steak House in St James leans into the theme proudly.
The lodge-like space feels intimate and relaxed. It's an easy place to settle in for a long, unhurried meal.
Bring a partner for the Porter House for 2. Filet mignon and lobster also get high marks here.
Starters show some range. Thai Calamari adds a twist, while Clams Casino keeps things classic.
Seafood fans can share the Seafood Platter. It's a nice way to kick off a special night.
Sides stay rich and filling. Stuffed potato, creamed spinach, and lobster mac and cheese all appear on the menu.
Finish with apple cobbler. It's a homey dessert that suits the lodge feel perfectly.
Outdoor seating is available in good weather. Dinner is the main focus, with doors opening in the late afternoon.
Reservations are recommended and often required. Free parking makes the visit simple.
Address: 433 N Country Rd, St James, NY 11780
10. The Capital Grille

Clubby rooms and dry-aged steaks go together like salt and pepper. The Capital Grille in Garden City nails that pairing.
The setting feels elegant and refined. It works well for date nights, business lunches, or family celebrations.
Steak options run deep. The aged filet on the bone, dry-aged New York Strip, and ribeye are all favorites.
Creamed spinach earns loud praise here. Mashed potatoes and Parmesan truffle fries keep the side game strong.
Craving something from the sea? Lobster and crab cakes make a rich starter.
The tuna tartare comes with avocado, mango, and sriracha. It's bright, fresh, and a fun contrast to the steaks.
Lobster mac 'n' cheese is another crowd-pleaser. Dessert brings cheesecake and coconut cream pie.
Kids are welcome, with a kids' menu and high chairs. That makes it easier to bring the whole family.
Lunch runs Monday through Saturday. Reservations are recommended, and valet parking is available.
Address: 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530
11. Bobby Van's Steakhouse

A Hamptons summer calls for steak and a sidewalk seat. Bobby Van's in Bridgehampton handles both with ease.
The clubby setting feels chic yet comfortable. A lively lounge keeps the energy up.
The menu goes well beyond beef. Lamb, veal, chicken, shellfish, and whole fish all make an appearance.
Steaks still steal the show, though. They come out cooked well and served with care.
Baked clams are a popular starter. They fit right in with the coastal South Fork mood.
Want something lighter? Salads and healthy options give you room to balance a big meal.
Outdoor seating is a real perk here. Dogs are even allowed outside, so your pup can join the fun.
Lunch and dinner run separately, with a break in the afternoon. Plan around that window before heading over.
Parking can be tricky, since spots fill up fast. Arrive a little early and make a dinner reservation.
Address: 2393 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
12. Jimmy Hays Steak House

Few things feel better than an owner who greets you at the door. Jimmy Hays Steak House in Island Park makes that a habit.
Steaks arrive cooked with care. The side dishes hold their own, so build a little sharing plate.
Seafood lovers have options too. Lobster Thermidor is a rich, classic choice that feels like a celebration.
Baked clams make an easy starter. They're a South Shore staple for good reason.
Want something casual? The Crab Cake Sandwich and McCluskey's Bar Burger offer a lighter way in.
The staff are attentive and courteous. Service here feels personal, which keeps people coming back.
Doors open in the late afternoon, and evenings stay busy midweek. Reservations are recommended for dinner.
Valet and street parking are both available. Save room for dessert and coffee before heading home.
Address: 4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558

















